Review: The Burrowers

Director: JT Petty
Year: 2008
Country: USA
In regard to my recent spate of negative reviews and outright hatred for most films fellow horror bloggers seem to love, I was met with this reply on Twitter when I voiced my excitement for my soon-to-arrive copy of The Burrowers, writer/director JT Petty’s popular and well-received creature flick:
PeterSHall @Bradmchargue If you hate THE BURROWERS I seriously am done with you.
Now, I was going into this film blind. I had never seen a trailer, and all information on the film was gleaned from reviews. This is a recipe for disaster, as I apparently hate everything, but dammit, I LOVE period horror films and feel that the horror genre suffers from a gross lack of films centered on such time periods at the Salem Witch Trials, the Crusades, and the Civil War, among others.
The Burrowers is a well-crafted creature flick that manages to suck you in with a slow reveal of the antagonists, providing an adequate and believable level of tension lacking in most contemporary horror films. Set in the Dakota Territories in 1879, a family is kidnapped from what is assumed to be Native Americans. Fergus Coffey, an Irish immigrant whose love MaryAnne was one of the abducted, assembles a small posse and goes off in search of the family and their abductors. As the search continues, it becomes all too evident that Native Americans are not behind the abduction, and that something far more sinister is too blame.
Much of the film is spent trying to gain an understanding of who, or what, the Burrowers are, told mainly through the interrogation of Indian prisoners. Interspersed with the gruesome discoveries of their victims, Petty manages to keep the ultimate reveal until the end of the film, preferring instead to focus on the characters, their relationships, and for some, the inevitability of their deaths. The method of dispatch the Burrowers use is creative, eschewing the outright consumption of their victims in favor of a slow, painful, and most importantly, aware death.
My biggest qualm with the film, however, is found in the creature design. While their basic physical construction was unique and indeed pretty creepy, their faces managed to make me laugh more so than tremble with fear. They vaguely resembled an enemy from Doom 3, yet one that suffers from Down Syndrome. If you click the above link you’ll see what I mean, and if you vocalize the stereotypical sound a moron might make when you do you’d have an idea of what I thought every time they appeared on the screen. This response is seemingly a death knell for a film of this sub-genre, yet somehow managed to be relatively insignificant in terms of the film’s overall appeal. The characters were solid if just a little derivative, especially in the case of Henry Victor, the despotic leader of the cadre that initially sets out to find the missing family. Insistent on the notion that Native Americans are behind the abduction, he resorts to torture in order to force confessions.
JT Petty is a writer/director to keep an eye on. Comparisons have been drawn (by me) to Neil Marshall, whose creature flick The Descent is on par with The Burrowers in terms of impact on the contemporary horror industry. With luck his follow-up flick will be on the same level as The Burrowers, and if met with the same level of fanfare, will solidify him as a major force in the horror industry.







Based on the Richard Matheson short story “Button, Button,” which was adapted into a Twilight Zone episode, The Box synopsis belies the Saw-like qualities found in the trailer. B-D 




